March 10, 2010





more diavlogs



View Thread Post Comment
JackLifton wrote on 07/04/2009  at  09:57 PM
Re: UN Plaza: Conflict Minerals (Mark Leon Goldberg & David Sullivan)
This is a very poorly done piece. The gentlemean who professes to be an expert in "conflict minerals" is not. All of the "metals" mentioned in the piece are sourced overwhelmingly from Maylaysia and Brazil (tin), Australia and Brazil (tantalum), the Peoples Republic of China (tungsten), and the Republic of South Africa, The United States, Canada, Russia, and China (gold). Minerals used to produce metals that are mined in the Democratic Republic of the Congo by "artisanal" miners are smuggled out to avoid taxes and produced without any regard for the health or safety of the miners. The minerals are processed by western and Chinese companies who fabricate certificates of origin-this seems unknown to your expert-and pay far below market prices.
The various thugs and warlords who use slaves to produce these minerals are abetted by the end-users who get a cost advantage by ignoring the suffering of the actual workers and the laws of the DRC and the global market place for metals and minerals.
Sincerely, Bob, you should avoid having pieces like this; it makes you look foolish and shallow.
View Thread Post Comment
bjkeefe wrote on 07/04/2009  at  10:10 PM
Re: UN Plaza: Conflict Minerals (Mark Leon Goldberg & David Sullivan)
Quoting JackLifton: [...]
Seemed to me that most of your points were in fact made in the diavlog, if perhaps not emphasized as you have done. In particular, I came away from listening to it understanding that the four minerals in question are not primarily obtained from the troubled countries, that Congo is more of a smuggling point than a producer, and that obfuscation on the receiving end is one of the main impediments to addressing the bad situations in the central African mines.
View Thread Post Comment
Ray wrote on 07/05/2009  at  10:58 AM
Re: UN Plaza: Conflict Minerals (Mark Leon Goldberg & David Sullivan)
Quoting JackLifton: The various thugs and warlords who use slaves to produce these minerals are abetted by the end-users who get a cost advantage by ignoring the suffering of the actual workers and the laws of the DRC and the global market place for metals and minerals.
Sincerely, Bob, you should avoid having pieces like this; it makes you look foolish and shallow.
Are you a crazy person?
The conversation here told precisely the same story you just outlined, only it went into further depth.
It was deeper--less shallow--than your post.
Are you all right? Do you need medication? Yours is one of the most batshit posts I've ever seen on bloggingheads, which is saying something!
View Thread Post Comment
AemJeff wrote on 07/06/2009  at  12:04 AM
Re: UN Plaza: Conflict Minerals (Mark Leon Goldberg & David Sullivan)
Quoting Ray: Are you a crazy person?
The conversation here told precisely the same story you just outlined, only it went into further depth.
It was deeper--less shallow--than your post.
Are you all right? Do you need medication? Yours is one of the most batshit posts I've ever seen on bloggingheads, which is saying something!
Ray, I think you might have overstated you objections. Most "batshit?" I think I might be able to find a counterexample or two if I look around the archives for second or two.
View Thread Post Comment
Ray wrote on 07/06/2009  at  09:56 PM
Re: UN Plaza: Conflict Minerals (Mark Leon Goldberg & David Sullivan)
Quoting AemJeff: Ray, I think you might have overstated you objections. Most "batshit?" I think I might be able to find a counterexample or two if I look around the archives for second or two.
1) JL obviously responded to the segment titles without listening to the conversation.
2) I replied to him as if he had actually listened to the conversation.
3) They wouldn't be counter-examples.
View Thread Post Comment
AemJeff wrote on 07/06/2009  at  10:33 PM
Re: UN Plaza: Conflict Minerals (Mark Leon Goldberg & David Sullivan)
Quoting Ray: 1) JL obviously responded to the segment titles witho0ut listening to the conversation.
2) I replied to him as if he had actually listened to the conversation.
3) They wouldn't be counter-examples.
I'll give you one and two. As long as we're discussing a superlative claim ("most,") I think I'll stand by my use of the word "counterexample."
View Thread Post Comment
Michael wrote on 07/11/2009  at  03:57 PM
Re: UN Plaza: Conflict Minerals (Mark Leon Goldberg & David Sullivan)
Thanks guys for highlighting the issue of "conflict minerals". I never really gave this any thought before. A worthwhile and professionally conducted Q & A.




uncle ebeneezer: Is Tom purposely trying to steer interest away from his profession? 

themightypuck: Bob the Baptist comes out. 

uncle ebeneezer: Will formulates a scenario where the terrorists, literally, win! 

sapeye: Hmmm, is Bob guilty of serious stereotyping? 

Stapler Malone: No, Bob. It’s not. Nothing ever is.  

d7greene: Lawrence Lessig knows a juice-boxer when he sees one. 

Toryentalist: Matt is great, Matt is great—listen and repeat. 

thouartgob: Joel’s elegant refutation of Bob’s point. 

uncle ebeneezer: George Johnson, hopeless romantic! 

themightypuck: Robert Wright, Asteroid Cowboy. 

bjkeefe: Spelling is fun-damental! 

nikkibong: The joy of taking stuff out of context. 

bjkeefe: Who stole Matthew’s tie? 

uncle ebeneezer: The Art of Subtlety. 

bjkeefe: Heather slaps the entire BhTV community. 

bjkeefe: Can anyone find a case where this is not ultimately Mickey's advice to Dems? 

Ken Davis: The racial blind taste test. 

Stapler Malone: Go forward, not backward; upward not forward; and always twirling, twirling, twirling towards freedom.... 

Simon Willard: Bob steps outside himself here. 

JonIrenicus: Puzzle spelled out. 

uncle ebeneezer: George's response here was absolutely priceless. 

graz: Bob takes Tom Jones down a peg. 

bjkeefe: Entry for a video dictionary: "unflappable." 

almostaquantum: Hooray: Jonah Goldberg dismisses the ticking time-bomb scenario. 

uncle ebeneezer: Killing the American Dream. 

mailing list

Get a notification when a new diavlog is posted

subscriptions

audio podcast
video (iTunes)
RSS
twitter

store


Buy Bloggingheads T-shirts and mugs at CafePress

contact

Send your questions or comments to

community

Talk with other BhTV viewers in the forum